Online Dating Profiles

How to Pick Your Best Dating Profile Pictures Based on Photofeeler Scores

Posted on
Pick your best dating profile pictures

Got feedback from Photofeeler? Great. Now it’s time to do something with it.

How do you choose your best dating profile pictures once your test results are in?

We’re breaking down how to pick a good mix of photos, how to order them, how to avoid misrepresenting yourself, and more.

Step 1: Look at Overall High-Scorers (Duh 😛)

Smart, trustworthy, and attractive are the three dating-category traits on Photofeeler for a reason. Hitting all three will get you the best results on dating apps. (More on that point later.)

So first, find the “Sort” button near the top of your My Tests page, and select “Total Score” in order to see which photos did best overall.

Sort to see your best profile picture

Keep these high scorers in mind as you make your next considerations.

Step 2: Consider “Attractive” for Base-Level Swipeability

The best dating profile pictures all have a good attractiveness score
via GIPHY

As far as we currently know, the attractive trait on Photofeeler is most closely tied to right-swipes on Tinder.

What this means is, without any attractive photos, you’re unlikely to get any matches at all. But with photos that score above average in attractiveness, you ought to begin receiving matches.

If you’re a man, that is. If you’re a woman, you might still get matches with unattractive pictures because many men right-swipe on everyone and only look at the profiles later. But you’re unlikely to get genuine, enthusiastic interest.

So your attractive scores on Photofeeler should be the first ones you pay attention to.

Step 3: Consider “Smart” and “Trustworthy” for Match Quality

However, attractive scores are not the end of the story.

That’s because the quality of people behind those right-swipes goes up if your photos also look smart and trustworthy.

So attractive photos may pull you some low-quality matches. But nailing all three of these traits means you’ll hear from more interesting, more emotionally stable people.

Fact is, “like attracts like.” So if you portray smarts and trustworthiness, you’ll attract people with those traits. What’s more is these traits correlate with other desirable characteristics, such as responsibility, level-headedness, willpower, and ambition.

People who are attracted to smarts and trusworthiness are also more likely to be seeking a relationship than hookups.

Smart Trustworthy Attractive Who is attracted?
X No one*
X No one*
X X No one*
X Low quality matches (emotionally unstable, desperate, shallow, seeking lower-quality interactions)
X X Medium quality matches unlikely to be very smart themselves
X X Medium quality matches unlikely to be very trustworthy themselves
X X X High quality matches

*Women might still get matches from men who right-swipe on everyone and only look at the profiles later. Any messages will likely be hookup-centric. If you’re a man, you might match with scammers or bots.

Step 4: Consider the Story

So now we understand the role of the three traits, but there’s still another thing to consider:

Who are you? What are you like?

If you look at your top-scoring pictures, you’ll see they tell a story.

Say, for instance, your highest-scoring pics are all from the same photo shoot. Then you’ll notice that one of these pictures alone looks cool and interesting, but 6 of them altogether tells a story about a guy who spends a lot of time doing photo shoots by himself. (I’m not saying people are right to judge this, but they will.)

Or maybe your three best-scoring photos have you laugh-smiling at social events. This portrays you as extremely outgoing and happy. So, ask yourself: does this series of photos represent you a lot, a little, or not at all?

Maybe all your best profile pictures are of you laughing out loud

You don’t have to portray “bad” parts of yourself in order to make an honest profile. That is a total misconception. In fact, it’s perfectly normal and healthy to put your best foot forward at the beginning of any relationship.

But if your profile is a total and complete fiction — it paints a picture of someone who has completely opposite personality traits from you — you’re unlikely to attract matches who you’ll actually hit it off with.

Unfortunately, people screw this up all the time. Take, for instance, a guy who has a warm and empathetic demeanor in person, but he never smiles in pictures because he wants to seem tougher than he is. (But then he ends up looking like a total jerk, which is the literal opposite of who he really is.)

It’s also possible that your highest-scoring photos could leave out a physical detail that is a deal-breaker for some people. Like maybe you’re bald, and your best pictures have a hat on. Then you’ll want to include your highest-scoring photo that shows your bald head into your mix of dating photos, just to avoid wasting your time talking to the wrong people.

Good dating profile pictures weed out the right people
via GIPHY

To clarify, what I am not saying is that you should include your least attractive picture “in order to be honest” and deter anyone who “can’t handle you at your worst.” Literally this is the worst idea. If Brad Pitt included his least attractive picture, no one would right-swipe on him either. And the capacity to accept someone at their worst only comes later in a relationship, once a bond has been formed.

So, all in all:

  • Don’t use more than one picture in the same clothing and/or setting.
  • If you have a physical characteristic that is a known deal-breaker for some people, tastefully work a photo of it into your mix.
  • If many of your pictures got similar scores and you need a reason to pick one over another, choose a mix that best represents what you’re actually like in person. Accurately portraying yourself increases your chances of hitting it off with people you meet.

Step 5: Address Variety and Photo Ordering

Now, you may have realized in the last step that your profile could actually use some of your lesser-scoring photos in order to tell a better, more accurate story about yourself.

For instance, you might want to add more group shots, a picture of you in skiing gear, etc.

Here’s the best variety of photos and photo order to shoot for:

1st photo A photo with a clear view of your face. No one else is in the shot. Preferably this is your highest-scoring photo.
2nd photo Another photo of just you with a clear view of your face. Make sure your clothes and location are different.
Middle photos Add group pics, hobby photos where your face may not be clear.
Last photo Another photo of just you with a clear view of your face. Make sure your clothes and location are different. Preferably this is your second-highest-scoring photo.

And that concludes it.

I hope you now have a greater understanding of how to take your Photofeeler feedback into account when you choose your dating profile pics.

Realizing you don’t have all the photos you need yet to make a great profile? Try our advice for getting new pics, and we’ll see you back over at Photofeeler to test out your next batch.

Know for certain how you’re coming across in pictures with Photofeeler. It’s free to use here. 🙌

Share: